Opinion on these graphs

No description
No description
13 Replies
jhorn68 (V-Core 3.1 400)
I have heard that pattern could be result of I umbilical tightness
Supercrossed
SupercrossedOP•7mo ago
How do you mean? The umbilical in this case is a USB toolhead board and cpap fan
Supercrossed
SupercrossedOP•7mo ago
No description
Prav
Prav•7mo ago
as a rule of thumb, if the scale number , is in 1e3 range or low 1e4 you likely have issues related to belts not being tensioned, binding or rails binding.
No description
VisualTech48
VisualTech48•7mo ago
@Prav I think as well seeing ZV being 30k and MZV the lower being 1.5k there is some issues there.
Prav
Prav•7mo ago
When the scale is so low it's all noise, recommendations are just incorrect. Can also be caused by a bad mount for adxl Or broken adxl
Supercrossed
SupercrossedOP•7mo ago
Adxl is the beacon H The Y rails seem to have some binding/grinding. Reached out to fabreeko about them but been trying to fix them in the meantime
Ferfi
Ferfi•7mo ago
Y axis has higher frequency peak than X axis... Unless you have Hybrid VC4 (I don't see second Y motor) then this is very sus.
Prav
Prav•7mo ago
it doesn't have higher frequency, we don't know what the real frequency is, because some mechanical issues make the test result invalid, best you can say about it is that there's a problem.
from what people shown on v-cores Y axis on hybrid is nowhere close to being better than X axis anyway 😄
Ferfi
Ferfi•7mo ago
X peak is at 60 Hz, Y peak is at 87 Hz. Simple as. ofc as I wrote this fact itself points out that something is wrong
Prav
Prav•7mo ago
the simple diagnosis is that the graph shows vibrations 30-100x smaller than they normally are. No need to compare it to X at all. X better than Y isn't universally true on all types of machines (pretty much only on corexy) so it;s not the best way of diagnosing problems. It's also possible to have better Y than X on corexy if the X axis is the one with the problem.
Ferfi
Ferfi•7mo ago
Y value of the graphs doesn't show vibration "size". PSD says how much of the vibrations overall occurred at certain frequency. That's why you want the PSD as high as possible. If it is almost infinity then that means that resonance occurs only at infinitesimaly small frequency value
Supercrossed
SupercrossedOP•7mo ago
I'll re align everything. The X gantry is extremely smooth moving by hand but moving the Y axis by hand is very rough and grind-y Will adjust all belts and retension to run the test again

Did you find this page helpful?