Filament•2mo ago

getStateUsing() called 3 times on first load

Hey there, I just investigated some performance issues and noticed that each table that uses getStateUsing() has this function 3 times called on loading the table. So each query inside gets also executed 3 times! Why? Simple Example:

Tables\Columns\TextColumn::make('products')
   ->label('Products')
   ->badge()
   ->getStateUsing(function (Domain $domain) {
      \Log::debug('DomainResource::table::getStateUsing');
      return $domain->products()->count();
   })
,

Tables\Columns\TextColumn::make('products')
   ->label('Products')
   ->badge()
   ->getStateUsing(function (Domain $domain) {
      \Log::debug('DomainResource::table::getStateUsing');
      return $domain->products()->count();
   })
,

13 Replies

btxOP•2mo ago

Since I think now it is a bug after some hours of investigation, I reported this on GitHub https://github.com/filamentphp/filament/issues/14852

GitHub

Query inside getStateUsing called 3 times per row · Issue #14852 · ...

Package filament/tables Package Version v3.2.124 Laravel Version v11.33.2 Livewire Version default PHP Version 8.3.13 Problem description When using ->getStateUsing() to fill a column with a cus...

ericmp•2mo ago

@btx not sure if the problem is that u r making a query for each row to get the products count https://filamentphp.com/docs/3.x/tables/columns/relationships#counting-relationships

Tables\Columns\TextColumn::make('products_count')->counts('products')

Tables\Columns\TextColumn::make('products_count')->counts('products')

btxOP•2mo ago

Yea this would solve to problem for this specific example, but not when requiring any specialized query oder calculation for the colum, since the Closure is still called 3 times

ericmp•2mo ago

then idk, it may be debugbar

btxOP•2mo ago

its also replicateable when logging the calls to log file

ericmp•2mo ago

when u tested it, u disabled debugbar?

DEBUGBAR_ENABLED=false # .env

DEBUGBAR_ENABLED=false # .env

btxOP•2mo ago

I just checked with disabled debugbar, just with file logging, still 3 calls logged. I have a slight suspicion that this might be one of the reasons why the overall performance of v3 has become so much worse compared to v2. I just upgraded to M4 Pro, where I can't notice the lags anymore. But performance of v3 wasn't satisfying on my old 2019 MBP and i5-11400 desktop, and also its not in production.

ericmp•2mo ago

ohh, then im not sure. it may be yeah

raheel3031•2mo ago

What does this domain resource do?

btxOP•2mo ago

just shows the domains table

raheel3031•2mo ago

Yeah but are those sales channels??

btxOP•2mo ago

u mean some kind of laravel sales channels? no just a list of domains and products

raheel3031•2mo ago

Yes. Ah OK. I am looking to build sales channels. So basically use the same filament admin panel for multiple sales channels

Gaming

Programming

getStateUsing() called 3 times on first load

Did you find this page helpful?