Aid making a choice between cardigans

Outside of the Madewell garment being double the cost of the J.Crew cardigan and the difference in materials - Madewell has some wool - is there any reason to pick Madewell over J.Crew here? https://www.jcrew.com/p/BJ325?mode=add&N=LARGE&NUM_ITEMS=1&cartId=1a367956894ba77ac40de6c886&color_name=hthr-athletic-grey&selectedShipmentId=HOME https://www.madewell.com/cotton-merino-wool-blend-cardigan-sweater-99107248572.html
J.Crew
Heritage 14 oz. fleece cardigan sweater
Shop for the Heritage 14 oz. fleece cardigan sweater for men. Find the best selection of men mens-categories-clothing-sweatshirts-and-sweatpants-heritage available in-stores and on line.
3 Replies
Spuck
Spuck•3mo ago
Do you prefer the cut of one over the other? Wool will be a little warmer The Madewell one shows as cheaper to me (probably because 🇬🇧 )
SpicyOcelot
SpicyOcelot•3mo ago
The j crew cardigan is made of sweatshirt material, not really typical knit fabric for cardigans. That may or may not matter to you.
zeometer
zeometer•3mo ago
j crew cardigan is on final sale; in my experience it's been rather hit or miss especially for knits and i don't know if i'd roll the dice on something nonreturnable