Do I take the tight shoulders just to have sleeves that aren't long?

This is the difference between L and XL - I checked the measurements and it checks out - the relaxed shoulder fit of 50cm shoulder width is ideal - and the Large has 47.5 in shoulder width but I'm worried the sleeves are going to be way too long that being said, I'll likely wear this with rolled sleeves and tucked what do you guys think - shirt in question attached