Which suit should I keep?
Which of these should I keep? I like the fit of the 2nd one more overall but it has minor shoulder divots and the first one is overall smoother
16 Replies
1st one fits better
2nd one just looks too small all around
1st fits better by miles
1
First is much better
1
What is it about number 2 you like? It looks too small - shoulders narrow, pulling across the chest. First one much better in these areas.
another photo of #2 (this one's actual color, in the photos I sent earlier I artificially increased the exposure to bring out the wrinkles)
It has thicker material and more padding along the shoulders, and I generally prefer the slightly more angled shoulders. Also, I think I prefer the flapped pockets over jetted, and I think the lapels in #1 are too wide
#1 feels big/baggier when I wear it for some reason, and the material along the shoulders is a lot thinner
they're both the same listed size, but #1 is from suitsupply and #2 is from spier & mackay
Do you think maybe #2 one size up would be the best of both worlds?
If you want the thinner lapels and flapped pockets then I would try sizing up on #2. But as it stands I think 1 is really flattering on you.
I definitely defer to your taste but I really really love how 1 fits you.
I’d at least size up for 2. The jacket is also too short in the sleeves and overall length among other small things
I think I will return #1 for now, order a sized up version of #2, and recompare
Thanks for the advice everyone
Anytime!
New suit arrived today! Left is new, right is the old #2
left is loads better
I think so too
Lesson learned: suit supply suits run larger than spier & mackay