C#•2w ago

Pokemon Game SRP

Sorry I have a question about a game, I am making project for my uni about a pokemon game, the question is the next, I want to do the SRP principle of solid but I don't find a another posibility that make takedamage a method of each pokemon, is that bad? my setters are private because I don´t want them to be public, but I find that makeing and takeing damage should be a game mechanics class responsability

12 Replies

TheRanger•2w ago

What did you try so far, can you show some code?

Omnissiah•2w ago

also i believe it depends on what the rules for taking damage are

ManuOP•2w ago

This is my pokemon

namespace ClassLibrary;

public class Pokemon : IPokemon
{
    public string Name { get; private set; }
    public int Damage { get; private set; }
    public int Defense { get; private set; }
    public int Health { get; private set; }
    public int Estado { get; private set; } // 0  es normal, 1 burn, 2 poison, 3 paralyze , 4 sleep
    public string Tipo { get; private set; }

   
    public void DecreseHealth(int valueAfterCalculation) // Resta de vida despues del calculo de daño. 
    {
        Health -= valueAfterCalculation;
        if (Health < 0) Health = 0;
    }
    public Pokemon(string name, int damage, int defense, int health, string tipo)
    {
        Name = name;
        Damage = damage;
        Defense = defense;
        Health = health;
        Tipo = tipo;
        Estado = 0; // Por d el Estado es normal.
    }
    
}

namespace ClassLibrary;

public class Pokemon : IPokemon
{
    public string Name { get; private set; }
    public int Damage { get; private set; }
    public int Defense { get; private set; }
    public int Health { get; private set; }
    public int Estado { get; private set; } // 0  es normal, 1 burn, 2 poison, 3 paralyze , 4 sleep
    public string Tipo { get; private set; }

   
    public void DecreseHealth(int valueAfterCalculation) // Resta de vida despues del calculo de daño. 
    {
        Health -= valueAfterCalculation;
        if (Health < 0) Health = 0;
    }
    public Pokemon(string name, int damage, int defense, int health, string tipo)
    {
        Name = name;
        Damage = damage;
        Defense = defense;
        Health = health;
        Tipo = tipo;
        Estado = 0; // Por d el Estado es normal.
    }
    
}

some word are in spanish I reached this, not find another to make damage to my pokemon, but I find it should be a game mechanics thing

TheRanger•2w ago

yeah there are formulas online on how to calculate a pokemon taking damage

TheRanger•2w ago

https://bulbapedia.bulbagarden.net/wiki/Damage this one look good

Bulbapedia

Damage

Damage (Japanese: ダメージ damage) is a loss of a Pokémon's HP that happens as the result of a physical or special attack used against it by another Pokémon.

TheRanger•2w ago

atleast make Estado an enum, this way you can have named integers

ManuOP•2w ago

I mean if it should be a method of the pokemon I assume that yes because I don't find another way

TheRanger•2w ago

yes it should be only a single method, you can call it TakeDamage or something that has a parameter of Pokemon or if u want to apply SRP you could put it in a class called DamageCalculator

ManuOP•2w ago

Thanks you so much I am doing a uni project we should be a team but Only two of us are workings we are four so it is a very hard time

tisky1964•2w ago

@Manu what year are you I just started a c# class my first year

ManuOP•2w ago

first year too

tisky1964•7d ago

@Manu Im guessing ur at uni im just taking a community class to recover from injury but we haven’t gone over constructors yet 😭

Gaming

Programming

Pokemon Game SRP