does this poplin shirt work style wise like a white OCBD?

Hey folks, I got this white "paper poplin" shirt recently hoping for it to fill a white OCBD hole in my closet. I'm not sure if this fabric and cut are as versatile as a regular white OCBD. I want it function casually/slightly dressy. Hoping to get some second thoughts!
No description
No description
8 Replies
shootfilmnotbullets
Initial reaction is the fabric looks not textured enough. Not sure what’s happening with the fold/crease by the buttons That to me is more concerning than the fabric
okaylama
okaylama5mo ago
The fabric is lightweight and somewhat crinkly, I suppose that's why it's giving that creasing?
Guatemalean Toupee
Hmmm the poplin is definitely giving a pretty formal vibe, that along with the fit of the shirt kinda makes it look like a short dress shirt (which doesn’t really work imo) instead of a flowy casual shirt Is there a reason why you don’t want to get an Oxford cloth OCBD? I think one of those would be a hair more casual but look better in nearly all applications
okaylama
okaylama5mo ago
ty! It does kind of look like a short dress shirt Honestly it was on sale and I was hoping it would function like a regular OCBD, but I'm glad I got y'all thoughts on it I will probably hunt for a second hand OCBD instead
Guatemalean Toupee
Ooo yeah if you’re in the US, eBay has so many nice OCBD’s for sub $20 it’s hard to go wrong
okaylama
okaylama5mo ago
Yee sounds like eBay is the move! ty
zeometer
zeometer5mo ago
yall are driving up the market recommending eBay for OCBDs :keepincool: fwiw i have a similar poplin shirt that i still keep as a surrogate dress shirt (on laundry day, to wear under sweaters, etc.)
okaylama
okaylama5mo ago
true I suppose that it is still decently versatile, but I don't really wear enough "dress shirts" to warrant it over a more white casual button down