Select::createOptionUsing not updating selected element in v3

I can't make it work. I'm using v3.0.39
Here is an dummy example

Select::make('test')
->options(function(){
    return Tag::pluck('name','id');
})
->createOptionForm([TextInput::make('name')])
->createOptionUsing(function($data){
    $tag = new Tag();
    $tag->fill($data);
    $tag->save();
    return $tag->getKey();
})

Select::make('test')
->options(function(){
    return Tag::pluck('name','id');
})
->createOptionForm([TextInput::make('name')])
->createOptionUsing(function($data){
    $tag = new Tag();
    $tag->fill($data);
    $tag->save();
    return $tag->getKey();
})

The record is created but the select doesn't reflect the change. Thanks in advance

26 Replies

toeknee•15mo ago

Q.. Why not use:

->relationship(name: 'author', titleAttribute: 'name')
    ->createOptionAction(
        fn (Action $action) => $action->modalWidth('3xl'),
    )

->relationship(name: 'author', titleAttribute: 'name')
    ->createOptionAction(
        fn (Action $action) => $action->modalWidth('3xl'),
    )

as per the docs?

Fabien K.OP•15mo ago

Because it's not a real eloquent relationship in the model.

toeknee•15mo ago

So make it a relationship? since tag is a table on its own?

Fabien K.OP•15mo ago

Thanks for the suggestion but it's not possible. My implementation (which I cannot share) is more complicated than the example. I simplified it to demonstrate the issue. ( It was working in v2 btw). So we're not supposed to use createOptionUsing anymore ?

toeknee•15mo ago

Ah ok

Fabien K.OP•15mo ago

Sorry I fixed the example, the class wass wrong I tried with a real relationhship and I have the same result. Select is not filled after creating an item

LeandroFerreira•15mo ago

return $tag ?

Fabien K.OP•15mo ago

Select::make('tagsCategory')
->relationship('tagsCategory','name')
->createOptionForm([
    TextInput::make('name'),
    Hidden::make('group')->default('product_category'),
])->label('real relationship')

Select::make('tagsCategory')
->relationship('tagsCategory','name')
->createOptionForm([
    TextInput::make('name'),
    Hidden::make('group')->default('product_category'),
])->label('real relationship')

Here is the code I used for the real relationship test (like in the doc)

LeandroFerreira•15mo ago

Is it creating the record?

Fabien K.OP•15mo ago

It's creating the record. The issue is just the select field not updating with the created record

LeandroFerreira•15mo ago

Select::make('tag_category_id') ? What is the column name?

Fabien K.OP•15mo ago

It's a morphToMany relationship so no column name

LeandroFerreira•15mo ago

->multiple() ?

Fabien K.OP•15mo ago

oh yes that can explain why it's not working on the real relationship example not a good example then 😄 Ok so i did another test with a single relationship

LeandroFerreira•15mo ago

real relationship? What does it mean? If you are using morph, you should use morphto relationships.. ? https://filamentphp.com/docs/3.x/forms/fields/select#handling-morphto-relationships

Select - Form Builder - Filament

Fabien K.OP•15mo ago

Another simpler test

php 

    public function tag(){
        return $this->belongsTo(Tag::class);
    }

php 

    public function tag(){
        return $this->belongsTo(Tag::class);
    }

php 
 Select::make('tag_id')->relationship('tag','name')
  ->createOptionForm([
      TextInput::make('name'),
      Hidden::make('group')->default('product_category'),
  ])->label('real single relationship'),

php 
 Select::make('tag_id')->relationship('tag','name')
  ->createOptionForm([
      TextInput::make('name'),
      Hidden::make('group')->default('product_category'),
  ])->label('real single relationship'),

It seems to be a frontend issue, The select field does not reflect the change but the state seems to be ok after creating.

Fabien K.OP•15mo ago

LeandroFerreira•15mo ago

why is it working here? https://demo.filamentphp.com/shop/orders/1/edit try to add a customer

Fabien K.OP•15mo ago

that's my question. why it's not working 😄 Yeah it works fine

LeandroFerreira•15mo ago

maybe you can clone https://github.com/filamentphp/demo and compare to your project.. similar

Forms\Components\Select::make('shop_customer_id')
    ->relationship('customer', 'name')
    ->searchable()
    ->required()
    ->createOptionForm([
        Forms\Components\TextInput::make('name')
            ->required(),
...

Forms\Components\Select::make('shop_customer_id')
    ->relationship('customer', 'name')
    ->searchable()
    ->required()
    ->createOptionForm([
        Forms\Components\TextInput::make('name')
            ->required(),
...

did you try to remove hidden field, as a test?

GitHub

GitHub - filamentphp/demo: Source code for the demo.filamentphp.com...

Source code for the demo.filamentphp.com website. Contribute to filamentphp/demo development by creating an account on GitHub.

Fabien K.OP•15mo ago

cleared cache, forced asset update, no more idea yes I made my first tests without the hidden field I'll try the demo well I'm out of ideas. Same version of filament and livewire on the demo and my test project and still not working on my test project. removed all vendors. reinstalled. cleared all caches. republished assets. no luck. When I add ->searchable() it's working.

LeandroFerreira•15mo ago

weird, can you share the project on github?

Fabien K.OP•15mo ago

hhm not really. But I did try to remove searchable on the filament demo (customer field in the order resource) (don't forget to delete some customers first) and it's not working either. So it seems to be a bug when not searchable

LeandroFerreira•15mo ago

hum You can open an issue on GitHub, but honestly, I don't think it's a significant problem because you can use "searchable + preload.

Fabien K.OP•15mo ago

yeah, i'll just put seachable+ preload. Thanks for your time

Ben•15mo ago

oh wow, i have the exact same problem and the same solution. @fabien.karsegard do you work with multi tenancy? With searchable and preload it works. Thanks for this 😄 ...

Gaming

Programming

Select::createOptionUsing not updating selected element in v3