A
Admincraft•2y ago
LeSuisse

Poll: Plugin Based Server or Mod Based Server

Hi, quick questions for players, what do you prefer, Plugin Based Server (PBS) or Mod Based Server (MBS)? Note: MBS require custom launcher or custom configuration, PBS just require Minecraft launcher or any other launcher. MBS are much more customisable check #UI for more infos PBS don't require any special config, just know the IP and connect yourself. If u can say MBS / PBS is good but if you can explain why, that's even better !
59 Replies
Admincraft Meta
Admincraft Meta•2y ago
Thanks for asking your question!
Make sure to provide as much helpful information as possible such as logs/what you tried and what your exact issue is
Make sure to mark solved when issue is solved!!!
/close !close !solved !answered
Requested by lesuisse#0
ProGamingDk
ProGamingDk•2y ago
mbs is a mess to manage, and public servers are just not gonna go great unless u have alot of previous experience and mod developing experience
LeSuisse
LeSuisseOP•2y ago
So, what do you think is the best ? Public server = PBS ?
ProGamingDk
ProGamingDk•2y ago
plugin
LeSuisse
LeSuisseOP•2y ago
Ha, didnt realize it was you:moderator:
MrMcyeet
MrMcyeet•2y ago
MBS are much more customisable check #UI for more infos
While not 100% the same, most of those custom UIs you mentioned can be made with plugins (and no client side modifications) @LeSuisse But to answer your question, you should use plugins Much less messy both to manage and internally also, they're less hassle for the players A server that you can just click play and start playing will get exponentially players than one that you have to go out of your way to download and install a custom modpack for
LeSuisse
LeSuisseOP•2y ago
Please tell me how, in #UI or by mp but please let me know That's what i thought
MrMcyeet
MrMcyeet•2y ago
Using a plugin like Oraxen or ItemsAdder, you can achieve custom GUIs Pair that with a plugin like HappyHud you can get a custom in-game UI (i.e. custom hunger bar, etc)
LeSuisse
LeSuisseOP•2y ago
Thx Do u know where can i found help for that ? @Livor Mortis Pls
MrMcyeet
MrMcyeet•2y ago
In their respective communities
LeSuisse
LeSuisseOP•2y ago
okay thx and sorry for the ping Does free plugin exist ?
Discount Milk
Discount Milk•2y ago
You can build either of them for free iirc, but they don't provide support unless you pay.
ProGamingDk
ProGamingDk•2y ago
only oraxen itemsadder is closed source
LeSuisse
LeSuisseOP•2y ago
iirc = ?
ProGamingDk
ProGamingDk•2y ago
iirc = if i remember correctly
LeSuisse
LeSuisseOP•2y ago
i dont think closed source is really a good choice... no ? if they stop maintain i can directly go to trash
ProGamingDk
ProGamingDk•2y ago
they have maintained it for like 6 years or smth (not really 6 years but not sure the length)
Discount Milk
Discount Milk•2y ago
Oh, I thought there was a Jenkins link or something for IA
ProGamingDk
ProGamingDk•2y ago
nop
Discount Milk
Discount Milk•2y ago
:boxNoted:
MrMcyeet
MrMcyeet•2y ago
For plugins like that that've been around forever, it doesnt matter It isnt really reasonable to expect everything in your server to be open source
Discount Milk
Discount Milk•2y ago
For plugins in general- support for them can stop at the drop of a hat. OSS or otherwise. Unless you make it yourself, you can't guarantee it'll get support forever.
LeSuisse
LeSuisseOP•2y ago
Do you know if someone already made it ? happyhud with clickable buttons, and with oraxen ? And if he make it what's the result or if he have made a wiki / tutorial ' ? i search it for hours and found nothing
ProGamingDk
ProGamingDk•2y ago
happyhud doesnt make clickable buttons
LeSuisse
LeSuisseOP•2y ago
uh so what kotlin enthusiat was thinking ?
ProGamingDk
ProGamingDk•2y ago
well as i said u cant get exactly what u showed
MrMcyeet
MrMcyeet•2y ago
(custom) Clickable guis aren't done with happyhud They're done with oraxen/IA
ProGamingDk
ProGamingDk•2y ago
^^
MrMcyeet
MrMcyeet•2y ago
@LeSuisse but they are possible
ProGamingDk
ProGamingDk•2y ago
not everything
LeSuisse
LeSuisseOP•2y ago
and how can thinks be clickabe ther than in a "chest-like" GUI
ProGamingDk
ProGamingDk•2y ago
if he wants everything on em to be interactive
LeSuisse
LeSuisseOP•2y ago
? dont undestand your last sentence
MrMcyeet
MrMcyeet•2y ago
The button positions would be confined to what is possible in a chest, but the layout, textures, and GUI of the custom guis can all be replicated
ProGamingDk
ProGamingDk•2y ago
^^
LeSuisse
LeSuisseOP•2y ago
oh well, i see and clickable button outside the chest frame isnt possible ?
ProGamingDk
ProGamingDk•2y ago
no. which is what i meant with u cant get it exactly the same
LeSuisse
LeSuisseOP•2y ago
oh now i see the real problem and bigger chest like diamond chest (a mod) cant be made ?
ProGamingDk
ProGamingDk•2y ago
no
MrMcyeet
MrMcyeet•2y ago
Not without pagination
ProGamingDk
ProGamingDk•2y ago
^ which still doesnt let u do waht u want
LeSuisse
LeSuisseOP•2y ago
uh plugins are good but limited 😦 i cant make what i wantr
ProGamingDk
ProGamingDk•2y ago
well u wouldnt be able to do this with server-side only mods anyways
MrMcyeet
MrMcyeet•2y ago
The only thing they can't (really) do is client side modifications Those are limited to what's possible with resource packs
LeSuisse
LeSuisseOP•2y ago
yes, sadly can i still put composant outside the box of, like money amount etc...
MrMcyeet
MrMcyeet•2y ago
composant?
ProGamingDk
ProGamingDk•2y ago
yes afaik but iirc they will be darker when u open the chest
LeSuisse
LeSuisseOP•2y ago
item sorry, it's late at home
MrMcyeet
MrMcyeet•2y ago
Well, no
LeSuisse
LeSuisseOP•2y ago
it's 1:33 AM at home
MrMcyeet
MrMcyeet•2y ago
You can put any data that needs to be displayed into the chest title And move it with control characters Then have the frame for it provide a background outside of the normal chest window
LeSuisse
LeSuisseOP•2y ago
okay thx and the max height of clickable component is ? 8 ?
MrMcyeet
MrMcyeet•2y ago
^^^
LeSuisse
LeSuisseOP•2y ago
okay
MrMcyeet
MrMcyeet•2y ago
The actual buttons are confined to whats possible in a vanilla chest
LeSuisse
LeSuisseOP•2y ago
double chest is okay too ?
MrMcyeet
MrMcyeet•2y ago
But the textures can be whatever you want Ye
LeSuisse
LeSuisseOP•2y ago
thx i have fully understood now thanks boys
MrMcyeet
MrMcyeet•2y ago
🫡

Did you find this page helpful?