overcoats: size up or true size?

im in the market for overcoats, and while i dont know my regular size in them, i learned that i could just grab one of my suit jackets and look at their sizing (36R). given that i plan to wear sweaters and other layers underneath the overcoat, should i size up to make room (38R)? but i also read online that overcoats already account for this by measuring more than the tagged size:
The label size of an overcoat should correspond to the size of your chest, just like a suit coat would. So if you have a 42 inch chest, you wear a size 42 jacket and a size 42 overcoat. Generally speaking, the chest of an overcoat will measure about four inches more than its tagged size – so a size 42 will be about 46", giving you room for your suit or sport coat underneath.
https://putthison.com/q-answer-overcoat-sizing-aaron-writes-to-ask/
Put This On
Q & Answer: Overcoat Sizing
Aaron writes to ask: When it comes to sizing, do overcoat sizes match suit sizing, or do you buy commensurately...
11 Replies
Soup
Soup5w ago
The easiest way to be sure if buying secondhand without the ability to try on would be to check the measurements provided by the seller P2P or Pit to Pit size is what you would be looking for as described above if trying on new coats then you could wear the clothes you would intend to wear under the coat to the store
awz5082
awz50825w ago
That and shoulder (seam to seam)
sevyche🇵🇭
sevyche🇵🇭OP5w ago
yeah thats what i originally planned
awz5082
awz50825w ago
You generally want it a bit larger than your actual body measurements since you'll be wearing clothing under if you plan on layering or using it as an overcoat, make sure theres room Beyond that, it's just variance in cuts from brand to brand and what look you want to go for It's usually the same as your suit size tho, unless you plan on wearing it over suits
Meaty,
Meaty,5w ago
Rather than body measurements, I'd rec comparing with measurments of an item you have at home, or of something you try on in store, that has your goal fit already
awz5082
awz50825w ago
easiest one these days, if you dont have an item to compare with at home, is probably uniqlo, since they offer item measurements now
raisinpie
raisinpie5w ago
I'm also a 36r, my suit is 19"-20" p2p and my overcoats are 21"+
sevyche🇵🇭
sevyche🇵🇭OP5w ago
what do you typically wear under your overcoats?
raisinpie
raisinpie5w ago
all kinds of stuff lol the only thing that's iffy is my fleece because that is also chunky. I'm in the market for around 23" p2p rn but like, they are supposed to be huge because they need to fit over the chunkiest outfit you wanna wear.
sevyche🇵🇭
sevyche🇵🇭OP5w ago
what's your stature? im 5'9" ~140lbs
raisinpie
raisinpie5w ago
I am personally anti-body type dressing, important thing is I wear the same suit size as you!
Want results from more Discord servers?
Add your server