C#•2mo ago

Need help with AspNetCore and GUID.

Well I have got the following code for my register method in my webapi (Shown on first image. It is pretty simple). I am running my xUnit test for this method (everything is good) but it seems that I can't access my user.Id normally (I am returning it via "return Ok(user.Id);" line). Somehow debugger shows me that I have got two Id properties, one is actual Id and another just filled with zeros (shown on second photo). I would be grateful if someone explains me what is the problem with them and how can I access actual Id

17 Replies

Unknown User•2mo ago

Message Not Public

Beluga XDOP•2mo ago

May I ask what is the problem with Guid as an id? I saw just people in youtube use them so I was thinking it is default approach

Unknown User•2mo ago

Message Not Public

Beluga XDOP•2mo ago

Oh you mean that I won't use Id when I look for users? That what you mean?

MODiX•2mo ago

TeBeCo

REPL Result: Success

(
Guid.NewGuid(),Guid.NewGuid(),Guid.NewGuid(),Guid.NewGuid(),Guid.NewGuid(),Guid.NewGuid(),Guid.NewGuid(),Guid.NewGuid(),Guid.NewGuid(),Guid.NewGuid())

(
Guid.NewGuid(),Guid.NewGuid(),Guid.NewGuid(),Guid.NewGuid(),Guid.NewGuid(),Guid.NewGuid(),Guid.NewGuid(),Guid.NewGuid(),Guid.NewGuid(),Guid.NewGuid())

Result: ValueTuple<Guid, Guid, Guid, Guid, Guid, Guid, Guid, ValueTuple<Guid, Guid, Guid>>

{
  "item1": "c3375f83-0e0d-4c8b-936d-0eb6deab3fe5",
  "item2": "ada43a9e-363e-45d4-82b6-821f65ab03ac",
  "item3": "3985b5dd-158e-41e8-889b-9511e1d88469",
  "item4": "bb260775-38d3-446f-9572-afefccae1364",
  "item5": "f546f923-b879-4dcf-808e-3c627aceb7c7",
  "item6": "1cc12fee-4821-4626-be3f-42dfed711e53",
  "item7": "72cca71a-0cb3-4f27-bdfb-eac81d6222c1",
  "rest": {
    "item1": "956d8c78-46d1-42a5-8144-63c787ba2aea",
    "item2": "aff4d76b-8160-413d-9e0b-df7aadba35a6",
    "item3": "fa91fd81-df2b-410e-8212-1eb929950b89"
  }
}

{
  "item1": "c3375f83-0e0d-4c8b-936d-0eb6deab3fe5",
  "item2": "ada43a9e-363e-45d4-82b6-821f65ab03ac",
  "item3": "3985b5dd-158e-41e8-889b-9511e1d88469",
  "item4": "bb260775-38d3-446f-9572-afefccae1364",
  "item5": "f546f923-b879-4dcf-808e-3c627aceb7c7",
  "item6": "1cc12fee-4821-4626-be3f-42dfed711e53",
  "item7": "72cca71a-0cb3-4f27-bdfb-eac81d6222c1",
  "rest": {
    "item1": "956d8c78-46d1-42a5-8144-63c787ba2aea",
    "item2": "aff4d76b-8160-413d-9e0b-df7aadba35a6",
    "item3": "fa91fd81-df2b-410e-8212-1eb929950b89"
  }
}

Compile: 215.179ms | Execution: 22.803ms | React with ❌ to remove this embed.

Unknown User•2mo ago

Message Not Public

Beluga XDOP•2mo ago

Oh I see

Unknown User•2mo ago

Message Not Public

Beluga XDOP•2mo ago

Well fair point I understand now

Unknown User•2mo ago

Message Not Public

Beluga XDOP•2mo ago

Thank you for your explanation, will redo my db in that case (I used only Guids for ids in my dbs)

Unknown User•2mo ago

Message Not Public

Beluga XDOP•2mo ago

Oh I see, quite convinient in that case, I wanted to ask about it, because on my photo Id provided by AspNetCore was already in string

Unknown User•2mo ago

Message Not Public

Beluga XDOP•2mo ago

I see, thank you for your explanation, it really helped me

Unknown User•2mo ago

Message Not Public

MODiX•2mo ago

If you have no further questions, please use /close to mark the forum thread as answered

Gaming

Programming

Need help with AspNetCore and GUID.