why is buying by piece-type a bad idea?

@Ben (GSH) told me in #general-chat that it would be a bad idea to phase out my T-shirts for polos. I assume the underlying problem will be the "phasing out"... Why is it a better idea to buy outfits instead of categories?
56 Replies
Scott
Scott2mo ago
Probably because t shirts and polos are not always interchangeable
rej
rej2mo ago
The real question here is what are your thoughts on Teddy K?
carrion
carrion2mo ago
I think it's a good idea get rid of your tshirts, only children wear tshirts
Bigelow
Bigelow2mo ago
Basically 99% of polos are really boring and it takes a lot of effort to make them look good - moreso than a t shirt
rej
rej2mo ago
I think you should become polo shirt guy Buy one in every color
carrion
carrion2mo ago
A good polo with a large collar is unbeatable, like this
No description
carrion
carrion2mo ago
Wait you probably already have that saved as inspo
onkel_rosi
onkel_rosi2mo ago
Let me share my Pinterest boards real quick
onkel_rosi
onkel_rosi2mo ago
Rosario polito
Pinterest
Six figure on Pinterest
Explore a hand-picked collection of Pins about Six figure on Pinterest.
onkel_rosi
onkel_rosi2mo ago
Teddy GOAT haha
carrion
carrion2mo ago
Yeah dude lmao what do you like most about him
zeometer
zeometer2mo ago
seeing that this inspiration board has different types of shirts (some polo, some button down, some sweaters), i would argue against switching out fully to polo shirts
onkel_rosi
onkel_rosi2mo ago
Uhm, afaik that's a fashion discord and not about philosophy thus id refuse to answer 😅
zeometer
zeometer2mo ago
a bigger question would be what about this aesthetic is appealing to you
onkel_rosi
onkel_rosi2mo ago
Well, with phasing out my T-Shirts also I wanted to imply "keeping most of my dress shirts" but adding button downs is on my bucket list
Nayyyyy
Nayyyyy2mo ago
Me with a long sleeve button down polo 😎
onkel_rosi
onkel_rosi2mo ago
I like the formality. I really dislike wearing jeans to begin with so the natural progression would be chino (or formal pants) T-shirts are not flattering me. I like the polo to sit a bit snug around my *-ceps
Nayyyyy
Nayyyyy2mo ago
Going to your question: having versatile choices in the garments you own gives you leeway on dress codes, personal style, experimentation. If you're trying to do a capsule wardrobe you really need to be good at knowing your fashion/dressing needs. It requires self reflection and knowledge, which many people lack. Especially those starting a fashion self improvement journey
rej
rej2mo ago
You got ceps? That's what's up
onkel_rosi
onkel_rosi2mo ago
Biceps, triceps
Elvander
Elvander2mo ago
I lost some cep's in a card game so I'm down to a unicep, but I know how to dress for it. Requires strategic gussetting
onkel_rosi
onkel_rosi2mo ago
Ok. Maybe I should buy the basic bastard and combine it with chinos all the way through - to get a beginning
zeometer
zeometer2mo ago
i think that is a good idea but i would check to see if any of your clothes already work within the confines of this initial wardrobe
Talbot
Talbot2mo ago
Back to OP, I don't think it's a good idea to buy "outfits", I think the general idea is to buy things that work well with several other things in your wardrobe
bishopcorrigan
bishopcorrigan2mo ago
I will always recommend learning to put together an outfit and just seeing how you did before buying things
onkel_rosi
onkel_rosi2mo ago
Yeah, I am indexing my current wardrobe to then throw out all stuff that's not matching
bishopcorrigan
bishopcorrigan2mo ago
Just put on clothes and try to make it work, then you actually figure out what you’re missing Checklist purchasing is how you end up with too much shit you don’t need in the first place
Talbot
Talbot2mo ago
Another good way to cull the wardobe: discard anything not worn in over a year (minus the seasonal stuff)
bishopcorrigan
bishopcorrigan2mo ago
Stress test your wardrobe, that’s how you find the weak points and the excesses Then trim and add as you see it
Talbot
Talbot2mo ago
A long time ago I did what you are talking of doing, then I realized I don't like polo shirts all that much. Now I have a bunch of polo's I rarely wear.
zeometer
zeometer2mo ago
same
Talbot
Talbot2mo ago
So don't do that You'll still need t shirts for something Even if it's not just fashion or whatev I wouldn't call this a polo either, this is a short sleeve camp collar
onkel_rosi
onkel_rosi2mo ago
Or as we in Germany call it "Bus Driver Shirt"
onkel_rosi
onkel_rosi2mo ago
No description
onkel_rosi
onkel_rosi2mo ago
That's one of my better "casual" fits I was wearing in the winter time But does not translate that well into summer
zeometer
zeometer2mo ago
i think that without the sweater, with the sleeves rolled up some is a reasonable summer fit and while it's not the ideal picture to determine fit, it also looks like the button down fits well - you might be further along then you realize
onkel_rosi
onkel_rosi2mo ago
Nah dress shirt on its own looks stupid (on me) ocbd would be better there
Spuck
Spuck2mo ago
Paraboot Michaels and their consequences have been a disaster for the human race.
Talbot
Talbot2mo ago
Yeah don't discount the long sleeve shirt rolled up sleeves for summer look. That way the shirt gets dual use in summer and winter The reverse of short sleeve shirt in winter is not ideal, so it becomes a one season only item
onkel_rosi
onkel_rosi2mo ago
Maybe it's just the way the Uniqlo dress shirts fit. I need to get some more fitted ones
briquebrutale
briquebrutale2mo ago
nah bus drivers don’t rock camp collar shirts; they’ll wear any short sleeved shirt or at least that’s what is meant by that saying I rarely ever see true camp collar shirts in Germany
zeometer
zeometer2mo ago
that's a thought if this is your chosen aesthetic fit will be important especially if you choose to get the repro stuff in stores now vs actual vintage clothing
onkel_rosi
onkel_rosi2mo ago
I'll make an appointment at out local Charles tyrwitt store
sharloy
sharloy2mo ago
Can you send an example? I have yet to see a summer look with rolled up long sleeve that looks good
Talbot
Talbot2mo ago
I mean, it's just rolling your sleeves up a little
sharloy
sharloy2mo ago
Yea I mean I don’t think I’ve seen it look that great on a summer fit but I loved to be proven wrong Like it would just look better with a short sleeve or just not rolled up
Talbot
Talbot2mo ago
Same shirt different season, or weather
No description
No description
Talbot
Talbot2mo ago
Oh wait they're both rolled up I'm dumb ha
Talbot
Talbot2mo ago
No description
No description
onkel_rosi
onkel_rosi2mo ago
What pants can you guys recommend for hot days (28°C+)? We dont have a lot of AC in GER
briquebrutale
briquebrutale2mo ago
linen and thin cotton trousers wide fit trousers are generally better for hotter days leaves enough room between your skin and the fabric when walking
briquebrutale
briquebrutale2mo ago
Sites-DE-Site
Aus der aktuellen Uniqlo U Kollektion. Uniqlo U ist das Ergebnis eines engagierten und äußerst fähigen Teams internationaler Designer:innen unter der künstlerischen Leitung Christophe Lemaires mit Sitz in unserem Pariser Forschungs- und Entwicklungszentrum. - Leichter Twill.- Feingewebte Struktur mit eleganter Optik. - Angewinkelte Taschen auf d...
Talbot
Talbot2mo ago
Air circulates better too on loose fit
Elvander
Elvander2mo ago
High twist wool is king for heat if you can swing it.
onkel_rosi
onkel_rosi2mo ago
Hey guys, I am trying to formulate a framework for me here: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1oR9Yrl1MCT65wyrs-wlqoDsw3YU_GBP4dhqRkPUcCGY/edit?usp=sharing maybe you have some comments on that?
Google Docs
My Basic Bastard Framework
Info This sheet framework should help (me) decide what to buy and how much of it. When any extension is needed, simply copy the sheet and change it to suit your needs. It is created with an office-work and my taste in mind. (How often do you want to wash per week) Formaliy,Days / Week,Laundry t...
onkel_rosi
onkel_rosi2mo ago
First try, pulling it off ok?
No description
No description