C
C#5mo ago
Steak

[GIthub] Package that is not open source but with Public Visibility?

Hello, I want to create a small library as a package (lets say nuget or unity package manager), However I dont want my code to be open source (distributed as assembly .dll) with Public Repository in Github. Is it legal to do this?
17 Replies
Lê Duy Quang
Lê Duy Quang5mo ago
I don't see any legal stuff about that.
Anu6is
Anu6is5mo ago
are you asking if it's legal to make a library without a public GitHub repo? or do you want to make a public repo that is open to contributions
Steak
Steak5mo ago
I want to host a library/package, but the library/package is closed source. we can do it in C# by using DLL, so other developers cannot peek into it at the moment the Github Repo will be Public, so they can import the plugin for they own use that would be... ?
Lê Duy Quang
Lê Duy Quang5mo ago
It's fine.
Steak
Steak5mo ago
have you seen any similar case to this?
Lê Duy Quang
Lê Duy Quang5mo ago
Closest is just a repository with documentation.
Steak
Steak5mo ago
so you havent encounter a public repo with closed source files...? Repository with documentation usually only stores readme, documentation website files. But my case, I also host the source code (that is closed)
Lê Duy Quang
Lê Duy Quang5mo ago
If you put the source code into a public repository it's going to be publicly visible.
Steak
Steak5mo ago
thats okay, because the source code is in .dll format
Lê Duy Quang
Lê Duy Quang5mo ago
Then it's not source code, it's binary.
Steak
Steak5mo ago
well I couldnt say its a source code too. It's a compiled C# Library in a dynamic link library format
Lê Duy Quang
Lê Duy Quang5mo ago
Still it's a binary.
Steak
Steak5mo ago
that would be okay?
Lê Duy Quang
Lê Duy Quang5mo ago
It's fine.
Steak
Steak5mo ago
have you seen any similar case to this?
Anu6is
Anu6is5mo ago
Yes Not sure why you think this would be a legal issue
Steak
Steak5mo ago
Its just me havent seen anything like this Alright, from this conversation I got several Ideas. thanks @Anu6is @Lê Duy Quang