travel duffel bags

I've been looking for travel duffel bags that I can use as a carry on item. https://www.briggs-riley.com/collections/duffle-bags/products/garment-duffle I found this one, but it's a "garment bag". Is it stupid to buy a garment bag when you almost never wear a suit or is it still worth it? @BlackHorizon here you go.
Briggs and Riley
Garment Duffle
This 2-in-1 bag transforms from a duffle to a hanging garment bag, and back again for packing ease. Shop this lightweight, versatile bag now.
24 Replies
mattw282
mattw2825mo ago
@BlackHorizon it wasn't that hard
BlackHorizon
BlackHorizon5mo ago
ok thanks
bishopcorrigan
bishopcorrigan5mo ago
Is it “worth it” I mean almost certainly not, a regular duffle will hold more and cost a lot less Unless you travel a whole lot and need a crisp outfit for work I’m not sure why you would get one
BlackHorizon
BlackHorizon5mo ago
Any ideas on what kind of duffel bag looks sturdy like that and is more suited? I've looked at a lot of duffel bags and they all look like they're made of unsturdy material
bishopcorrigan
bishopcorrigan5mo ago
The base camp duffel is very sturdy if that’s the only requirement
mattw282
mattw2825mo ago
I've had a Patagonia black hole duffel for about 14 years and it's still going strong despite a lot of abuse.
BlackHorizon
BlackHorizon5mo ago
don't like the round shape
bishopcorrigan
bishopcorrigan5mo ago
Okay
BlackHorizon
BlackHorizon5mo ago
Also it needs to fit as a carry on, I don't think the 42L fits Not sure how to describe this but it looks like the briggs-riley bag has more structure to the bag than the blackhole and other likes it. It probably doesn't matter, but I'd prefer one that looks like it. I'll keep looking, but figured I'd ask in case anyone knows. My main question was if the garment bag is a bad choice or not so I got the answer for that thanks
mattw282
mattw2825mo ago
If you want to buy this bag just buy this bag. You don't need affirmation from strangers, especially if all you want to do is shoot down alternative suggestions because they don't meet requirements you never specified.
BlackHorizon
BlackHorizon5mo ago
No I asked a question and got the answer and said thanks already By sturdy just meant I want it to hold its shape even if it's empty. Maybe not the correct term to use, but I don't know the correct term to use
zeometer
zeometer5mo ago
Monos
Metro Carry-All Duffel
With spacious storage and thoughtful organization, the Metro Carry-All Duffel is perfect as a standalone bag for overnight getaways and weekend escapes, or as an addition to your luggage for longer journeys. The Metro Carry-All Duffel easily fits into overhead bins as a carry-on.
From An unknown user
From An unknown user
From An unknown user
BlackHorizon
BlackHorizon5mo ago
No it's the opposite for me, I'm not hauling a suit and was wondering if a garment bag was worth it if not.
zeometer
zeometer5mo ago
granted i just use a rolling carry-on half filled so i can buy stuff without having to deal with checked luggage returning
BlackHorizon
BlackHorizon5mo ago
I already got the answer to that question though
Elvander
Elvander5mo ago
The medium duffle is over his size limit, the small might do the job. It's not rigid but that range hold their shape pretty well the fabric is thick and strong.
shootfilmnotbullets
isn't carry on the sz limit? the medium was redesigned a little bit ago to "qualify" as a carry on, although I've even used my 72L field duffel as a carry on. Just depends on the person eyeing you board.
Elvander
Elvander5mo ago
Just going by his earlier comment https://discord.com/channels/1116793467654381685/1207680846262440018/1207689134991220756, but that sounds ideal then.
Discord
Discord - A New Way to Chat with Friends & Communities
Discord is the easiest way to communicate over voice, video, and text. Chat, hang out, and stay close with your friends and communities.
BlackHorizon
BlackHorizon5mo ago
the standard carry on size limit is 22" x 14" x 9" I think it's too tall. It looks good though It would probably get accepted as a carry on some times but it's risky if it doesn't adhere
Elvander
Elvander5mo ago
I'm the same, i never roll the dice it's such a pain in the ass if they make you check it.
BlackHorizon
BlackHorizon5mo ago
Not to mention they abuse your luggage and it gets lost some times
shootfilmnotbullets
huh, never had that issue with a duffel since it always smushes down
leroideskiki
leroideskiki5mo ago
@cdfchopper you’re way too nice