discord.js - Imagine an app•13mo ago

Different modal IDs still trigger awaitModalSubmit multiple times

I need the user to click the button and enter feedback in the modal. After submission, update the embeds in the original message and another notify message . However, if the user closes the modal midway and then re-clicks the button and submits, awaitModalSubmit will resolve multiple times, resulting in multiple updates. How to avoid this situation?

// Wait for feedback
const collector = await message.createMessageComponentCollector({
  componentType: ComponentType.Button,
  time: 600_000,
});
collector.on("collect", async (i) => {
  logger.debug(i.id);
  const modal = new ModalBuilder()
    .setCustomId(`feedback-${i.id}`)
    .setTitle("Give some Feedback!");
  // add input components
  await i.showModal(modal);

  i.awaitModalSubmit({
    time: 600_000,
    filter: collectorFilter,
  })
    .then((modalI) => {
      const feedback = modalI.fields.getTextInputValue("fbInput");
      embed.description =
        embed.description + `\nFeedback: ${feedback}`;
      logger.info(embed.description);

      // DB process

      return modalI.update({
        embeds: [embed],
        components: [],
      });
    })
    .then(() =>
      channelMessage.edit({
        embeds: [embed],
      }),
    )
    .catch((e) => {
      logger.debug(e.message);
      i.editReply({
        components: [],
      });
    });
});

// Wait for feedback
const collector = await message.createMessageComponentCollector({
  componentType: ComponentType.Button,
  time: 600_000,
});
collector.on("collect", async (i) => {
  logger.debug(i.id);
  const modal = new ModalBuilder()
    .setCustomId(`feedback-${i.id}`)
    .setTitle("Give some Feedback!");
  // add input components
  await i.showModal(modal);

  i.awaitModalSubmit({
    time: 600_000,
    filter: collectorFilter,
  })
    .then((modalI) => {
      const feedback = modalI.fields.getTextInputValue("fbInput");
      embed.description =
        embed.description + `\nFeedback: ${feedback}`;
      logger.info(embed.description);

      // DB process

      return modalI.update({
        embeds: [embed],
        components: [],
      });
    })
    .then(() =>
      channelMessage.edit({
        embeds: [embed],
      }),
    )
    .catch((e) => {
      logger.debug(e.message);
      i.editReply({
        components: [],
      });
    });
});

Here are the output after open modal three times: [01:58:03.598] DEBUG (27560): 1171388086941405195 [01:58:06.284] DEBUG (27560): 1171388098911948840 [01:58:08.420] DEBUG (27560): 1171388107808055337 [01:58:09.937] INFO (27560): Submission Approved! Status updated from In Review to Complete Feedback: 123 [01:58:09.937] INFO (27560): Submission Approved! Status updated from In Review to Complete Feedback: 123 Feedback: 123 [01:58:09.937] INFO (27560): Submission Approved! Status updated from In Review to Complete Feedback: 123 Feedback: 123 Feedback: 123 [01:58:10.117] DEBUG (27560): Unknown interaction [01:58:10.147] DEBUG (27560): Unknown interaction

7 Replies

d.js toolkit•13mo ago

- What's your exact discord.js npm list discord.js and node node -v version? - Not a discord.js issue? Check out #other-js-ts. - Consider reading #how-to-get-help to improve your question! - Explain what exactly your issue is. - Post the full error stack trace, not just the top part! - Show your code! - Issue solved? Press the button! - ✅ Marked as resolved by OP

Syjalo•13mo ago

Have different custom id for each modal or just handle modal submits in the interactionCreate event instead of collectors.

PurifiedWaterOP•13mo ago

I use ButtonInteraction id as modal id actually (.setCustomId(feedback-${i.id})), it's different every time but awaitModalSubmit still resolve multiple times...

Syjalo•13mo ago

It's not. As you said when user clicks the button 2 times it shows 2 models with the same custom id

PurifiedWaterOP•13mo ago

I add a logger here:

...
await i.showModal(modal);
logger.debug(modal.data.custom_id);
i.awaitModalSubmit({
...

...
await i.showModal(modal);
logger.debug(modal.data.custom_id);
i.awaitModalSubmit({
...

it really gave me different modal ID: [02:12:59.485] DEBUG (36040): feedback-1171391844618358805 [02:13:03.570] DEBUG (36040): feedback-1171391861789818991 [02:13:06.095] DEBUG (36040): feedback-1171391872426582026 Do I need to change other ID?

monbrey•13mo ago

You could add a check for the matching id in the filter

PurifiedWaterOP•13mo ago

It works! Thank you!

Gaming

Programming

Different modal IDs still trigger awaitModalSubmit multiple times