Best Allen Edmonds loafers?

Whole bunch of AE loafers are on sale for end -of-season right now. Several styles look sort of similar to each other. I'm looking for a true loafer (not a sneaker) but something casual enough to wear with shorts, casual linen pants, chinos. or even jeans. Recommendations?
4 Replies
gimp
gimp16mo ago
Half of full strap penny loafer is classic, and easier to be subtle with than horsebit or tassel. I'd get black, brown/etc, burgundy, or shell if they make it. I prefer mine to be simple. Calf (if not shell), smooth rather than pebbled, no big bold stitching / contrast stitching like you see sometimes. Similarly, as simple a sole as feasible. As thin as Goodyear welt usually is rather than chunky. Color matched rather than contrasting, though black under brown / burgundy isn't necessarily a deal breaker. I wouldn't say my preferences are best. Just that they are my preferences.
raisinpie
raisinpie16mo ago
I agree with gimp that penny is more subtle, and imo easier to pull off. I think horsebits look better in lazy luxe looks; I haven't figured out tassels yet. But here's some inspo for all 3 Edit: to answer your question tho, the cavanaugh is probably their most popular model
gimp
gimp16mo ago
Yeah I somehow forgot to mention suede. Oops. Suede can be great. Snuff, tobacco...
Bigelow
Bigelow16mo ago
the Cavanaugh loafer is pretty nice, LHS-esque silhouette. Dunno if any are on sale
Want results from more Discord servers?
Add your server