C#•16mo ago

❔ Hiya i am new to C# i am having problems with return method

    static void Main(string[] args)
    {
        Console.WriteLine("Hello World!");
        int PlayerPositionX = 5;
        int PlayerPositionY = 5;
        Add(PlayerPositionY, PlayerPositionX);
        Console.WriteLine(PlayerPositionX + " " + PlayerPositionY);
        //it should be both 10 10 but instead only printing 5 5 
    }
    public static int Add(int X, int Y)
    {
        X = X + X;
        Y = Y + Y;

        return X;
        return Y;

    }

    static void Main(string[] args)
    {
        Console.WriteLine("Hello World!");
        int PlayerPositionX = 5;
        int PlayerPositionY = 5;
        Add(PlayerPositionY, PlayerPositionX);
        Console.WriteLine(PlayerPositionX + " " + PlayerPositionY);
        //it should be both 10 10 but instead only printing 5 5 
    }
    public static int Add(int X, int Y)
    {
        X = X + X;
        Y = Y + Y;

        return X;
        return Y;

    }

thank you so much in advance

22 Replies

Kouhai•16mo ago

What are you trying to do? Return two values or mutate the passed ints?

m1ttenOP•16mo ago

well i am just try to update the two variables in my main class

Azrael•16mo ago

Just return X2 and Y2.

Kouhai•16mo ago

Well Console.WriteLine(PlayerPositionX + " " + PlayerPositionY); means the variables got mutated, no?

Azrael•16mo ago

Then you’d have to define them outside of main. private int X = 5 I’m on my phone, excuse my typos. How do you return two variables in an integer function? I’m so confused.

Kouhai•16mo ago

If you want to mutate the int variables you have to pass them by ref

public static int Add(ref int X, ref int Y)

public static int Add(ref int X, ref int Y)

This would make any modification to X and/or Y in the method body be reflected on the variables you passed

Add(ref PlayerPositionX, ref PlayerPositionY)

Add(ref PlayerPositionX, ref PlayerPositionY)

ValueTuple

m1ttenOP•16mo ago

oh i didnt know that

Azrael•16mo ago

Yes, but he’s not using one.

Kouhai•16mo ago

Yes, and so he won't be able to retrun two variables 😅

Azrael•16mo ago

That’s what I’m concerned about.

Kouhai•16mo ago

?? The compiler ignores the second return statement because it would never get executed

Azrael•16mo ago

His current function is wrong. You can’t return two integers from that function. Yeah. That’s what I’m saying? Unreachable code.

Kouhai•16mo ago

Ah, I thought you meant it should have a compile time error, my bad!

Azrael•16mo ago

I should’ve said that from the beginning. My fault.

m1ttenOP•16mo ago

well thank you this has been very informative i am gonner read up some documation about methods 🙂 have nice day/night/morning

Kouhai•16mo ago

Well, make sure to read this as well https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/dotnet/csharp/language-reference/builtin-types/value-types

Value types - C# reference

Value types vs reference types, kinds of value types, and the built-in value types in C#

Servator•16mo ago

You can't return multiple values like that

Azrael•16mo ago

We’ve discussed that already.

Tvde1•16mo ago

I would not recommend using ref for this. I'd recommend making a class Position with an X and a Y

Denis•16mo ago

Why create a clas when there is one already? Isn't Point available out of the box? Anyway, you could return a value tuple:

public (int x, int y) Add(int x, int y)
{
  return (x+x, y+y);
}

public (int x, int y) Add(int x, int y)
{
  return (x+x, y+y);
}

You use this method like so:

var (x, y) = Add(5, 10);

Console.WriteLine($"My X value is now {x}");

var (x, y) = Add(5, 10);

Console.WriteLine($"My X value is now {x}");

Alternatively

var result = Add(5, 10);

Console.WriteLine($"My X value is now {result.x}");

var result = Add(5, 10);

Console.WriteLine($"My X value is now {result.x}");

Tvde1•16mo ago

or with the above method:

var x = 1;
var y = 2;

(x, y) = Add(x, y);

Console.WriteLine($"Updated X and Y are: {x}, {y}.");

var x = 1;
var y = 2;

(x, y) = Add(x, y);

Console.WriteLine($"Updated X and Y are: {x}, {y}.");

Accord•16mo ago

Was this issue resolved? If so, run /close - otherwise I will mark this as stale and this post will be archived until there is new activity.

Gaming

Programming

❔ Hiya i am new to C# i am having problems with return method