C#•12mo ago

❔ C# dev kit completion "args"

Hey I'm trying vscode and I stumbled upon this behavior that seems strange. When it autocompletes after opening (), it completes with the named argument args even if I don't take it (by doing ", to input a string myself) Can I disable this behavior ?

40 Replies

Oxy•12mo ago

Result after inputing "

Oxy•12mo ago

I can prevent it by using Esc but it's boring to do for every methods

Oxy•12mo ago

You can observe exactly the same behavior on https://sharplab.io

SharpLab

C#/VB/F# compiler playground.

Oxy•12mo ago

But it has been a long time so I think it's not a particular issue of c# dev kit

333fred•12mo ago

Please use the command palette to file an issue on the C# extension (not devkit)

Oxy•12mo ago

Okay I just wanted to see if someone else was having the same issue

333fred•12mo ago

Hmm, actually, I cannot reproduce that

Oxy•12mo ago

Even on sharplab.io ?

333fred•12mo ago

Don't use sharplab as a testbed for this

Oxy•12mo ago

Okay you are not using copilot ?

333fred•12mo ago

I love it, but the editor support is terrible, and only marginally related to what vscode does

Oxy•12mo ago

Yeah you're right I'm saying that because the completion behavior is totally different with copilot

333fred•12mo ago

Copilot shouldn't have an impact on this behavior Really

Oxy•12mo ago

Yeah I'd like to rec a little something to show you But I'm not having the same issue at least

333fred•12mo ago

Not sure what copilot is doing for you there then. I cannot repro this with copilot enabled or disabled

Oxy•12mo ago

I should have showed that first

Oxy•12mo ago

C# is in prerelease as hinted when installing c# dev kit c# dev kit is not

333fred•12mo ago

They're both prerelease, but dev kit doesn't matter here The C# extension is what is providing completion I'm trying to figure out if there's some VSCode setting that controls accepting completions on "

Oxy•12mo ago

The interesting options I found in my settins.json

  "omnisharp.enableRoslynAnalyzers": true,
  "omnisharp.organizeImportsOnFormat": true,
  "omnisharp.enableLspDriver": true,
  "omnisharp.enableDecompilationSupport": true,
  "dotnet.inlayHints.enableInlayHintsForParameters": true,
  "dotnet.inlayHints.enableInlayHintsForLiteralParameters": true,
  "dotnet.inlayHints.enableInlayHintsForIndexerParameters": true,
  "csharp.inlayHints.enableInlayHintsForTypes": true,
  "dotnet.completion.showCompletionItemsFromUnimportedNamespaces": true,

  "omnisharp.enableRoslynAnalyzers": true,
  "omnisharp.organizeImportsOnFormat": true,
  "omnisharp.enableLspDriver": true,
  "omnisharp.enableDecompilationSupport": true,
  "dotnet.inlayHints.enableInlayHintsForParameters": true,
  "dotnet.inlayHints.enableInlayHintsForLiteralParameters": true,
  "dotnet.inlayHints.enableInlayHintsForIndexerParameters": true,
  "csharp.inlayHints.enableInlayHintsForTypes": true,
  "dotnet.completion.showCompletionItemsFromUnimportedNamespaces": true,

I also have this "editor.acceptSuggestionOnCommitCharacter": true I will disable it and try again

333fred•12mo ago

Oh, that could very well be it I have that off Yup, that's it

Oxy•12mo ago

Oh you can reproduce it now ?

333fred•12mo ago

This does still feel buggy to me though: " shouldn't be a commit character in an argument list Please do file that bug

Oxy•12mo ago

Okay your help was precious I have a track now I'm on azerty maybe that's related

333fred•12mo ago

Nope

Oxy•12mo ago

And linux (x11) That could be a x issue

333fred•12mo ago

We're saying that " is a character that should accept suggestions We shouldn't be doing that

Oxy•12mo ago

Yeah indeed

333fred•12mo ago

Trust me. It's not a bug related to your environment

Oxy•12mo ago

Okay I'll link that issue here as soon as I wrote it, is it good for you ?

333fred•12mo ago

👍

Oxy•12mo ago

(Just to be sure, I guess this is the window)

333fred•12mo ago

That's the one Good news: it may already be about to be fixed

333fred•12mo ago

https://github.com/dotnet/roslyn/pull/69327

GitHub

Emulate suggestion mode in LSP completion by always soft-select by ...

Fix dotnet/vscode-csharp#5732

Oxy•12mo ago

https://github.com/dotnet/vscode-csharp/issues/5988

GitHub

[Completion] " as commit character · Issue #5988 · dotnet/vscode-cs...

Type: Bug Issue Description When using the C# extension and with the option "editor.acceptSuggestionOnCommitCharacter": true " seems to be incorrectly considered as a commit characte...

Oxy•12mo ago

Oopsie I didn't see I can close it if you want

333fred•12mo ago

No worries

ero•12mo ago

I have this issue as well fwiw If this is a top-level file, args shows up because it's passed by default

Oxy•12mo ago

Yeah it's related to the commit option, if you disable it you won't have this issue anymore "editor.acceptSuggestionOnCommitCharacter": true This one, if you don't need it you can put that to false It's true by default It will be fixed soon anyway Oh but you're the ero from speedrun serv 👋

Accord•12mo ago

Was this issue resolved? If so, run /close - otherwise I will mark this as stale and this post will be archived until there is new activity.

Gaming

Programming

❔ C# dev kit completion "args"