C#•2y ago

❔ Is it worth to create lazy dictionary in this case?

I have following class: so as you see Add function add to the dictionary class TreeNode, it looks like a tree I made a lazy dictionary and my question is: is it worth it? Will it be better with simple dictionary?

3 Replies

SWEETPONYOP•2y ago

public class TreeNode
{
    public readonly Lazy<Dictionary<string, TreeNode>> _treeChildren = new();

    public bool Add(
        string[] subTopic,
        MqttDelivery delivery)
        => Add(subTopic, Level + 1, delivery);

    private bool Add(
         string[] topic,
         int level,
         MqttDelivery delivery)            
      {                 
         if (level >= topic.Length) 
         {                                                                  
              Topic = delivery.Topic;
              Header = delivery.Header?.ToJsonString( true );     
              Payload = delivery.Payload?.ToJsonString( true ); 
              Delivery = delivery;  
              AddToHistory( delivery );

              return false;
         }  
                                                                 
         var part = topic[ level ];                                          
         if (!_treeChildren.Value.ContainsKey(part))                         
        {               
             TopicsCount++;                                                  
            _treeChildren.Value.Add( part, new TreeNode( part, level, this));      
         }      
                                                             
         MessagesCount++;                                                    
         _treeChildren.Value[ part ].Add( topic, level + 1, delivery );                              return true;           
      }                                                                      
}

public class TreeNode
{
    public readonly Lazy<Dictionary<string, TreeNode>> _treeChildren = new();

    public bool Add(
        string[] subTopic,
        MqttDelivery delivery)
        => Add(subTopic, Level + 1, delivery);

    private bool Add(
         string[] topic,
         int level,
         MqttDelivery delivery)            
      {                 
         if (level >= topic.Length) 
         {                                                                  
              Topic = delivery.Topic;
              Header = delivery.Header?.ToJsonString( true );     
              Payload = delivery.Payload?.ToJsonString( true ); 
              Delivery = delivery;  
              AddToHistory( delivery );

              return false;
         }  
                                                                 
         var part = topic[ level ];                                          
         if (!_treeChildren.Value.ContainsKey(part))                         
        {               
             TopicsCount++;                                                  
            _treeChildren.Value.Add( part, new TreeNode( part, level, this));      
         }      
                                                             
         MessagesCount++;                                                    
         _treeChildren.Value[ part ].Add( topic, level + 1, delivery );                              return true;           
      }                                                                      
}

demidev_mb•2y ago

It's not a lazy dictionary, it's just lazily created dictionary. No it's not worth it Just use this

_treeChildren ??= new();

_treeChildren ??= new();

private readonly Dictionary<string, TreeNode> _treeChildren; // null

private readonly Dictionary<string, TreeNode> _treeChildren; // null

If it's public use property

Accord•2y ago

Was this issue resolved? If so, run /close - otherwise I will mark this as stale and this post will be archived until there is new activity.

Gaming

Programming

❔ Is it worth to create lazy dictionary in this case?