C#•2y ago

HTTPS Local Network No Content Case

I have an AspNetCore HttpGet Api that returns NoContent; is a simple Api for registering an number to the server. I also have other HttpGet Api that returns contents.

1) When the `NoContent` Api is accessed with domain name and https under the same machine where the AspNetCore Web Api is running, I get an error on the browser indicating `ERR_HTTP2_PROTOCOL_ERROR`. And the number is not registered.
This is by accessing the Api on the same machine through chrome with the URL of https://example.com
No option of `Proceed to localhost (unsafe)` is available.

1) When the `NoContent` Api is accessed with domain name and https under the same machine where the AspNetCore Web Api is running, I get an error on the browser indicating `ERR_HTTP2_PROTOCOL_ERROR`. And the number is not registered.
This is by accessing the Api on the same machine through chrome with the URL of https://example.com
No option of `Proceed to localhost (unsafe)` is available.

2) When the `NoContent` Api is accessed with `localhost` and either http or https under the same machine where the AspNetCore Web Api is running, I do not get an error. And the number is registered.
This is by accessing the Api on the same machine through chrome with the URL of http://localhost
With Https, I first get an `NET::ERR_CERT_COMMON_NAME_INVALID`, but after I clicked `Proceed to localhost (unsafe)`, the number is registered.
This is by accessing the Api on the same machine through chrome with the URL of https://localhost

2) When the `NoContent` Api is accessed with `localhost` and either http or https under the same machine where the AspNetCore Web Api is running, I do not get an error. And the number is registered.
This is by accessing the Api on the same machine through chrome with the URL of http://localhost
With Https, I first get an `NET::ERR_CERT_COMMON_NAME_INVALID`, but after I clicked `Proceed to localhost (unsafe)`, the number is registered.
This is by accessing the Api on the same machine through chrome with the URL of https://localhost

3) When the Api with content is accessed with domain name and https under the same machine where the AspNetCore Web Api is running, I am able to load the content successfully.
This is by accessing the Api on the same machine through chrome with the URL of https://example.com

3) When the Api with content is accessed with domain name and https under the same machine where the AspNetCore Web Api is running, I am able to load the content successfully.
This is by accessing the Api on the same machine through chrome with the URL of https://example.com

4) When the `NoContent` Api is accessed with domain name and https under different machine, I do not get an error. And the number is registered.
This is by accessing the Api on a different machine through chrome with the URL of https://example.com
This works either through internet, or on a different machine that connects with the server through PPTP VPN.

4) When the `NoContent` Api is accessed with domain name and https under different machine, I do not get an error. And the number is registered.
This is by accessing the Api on a different machine through chrome with the URL of https://example.com
This works either through internet, or on a different machine that connects with the server through PPTP VPN.

37 Replies

Up•2y ago

well you should not be using GET for mutating data, anyway. ..and then you'd just respond with 200 (ok) / 201 (created), not 204.

KKSK＠🌸🎵🌸🎵🌸•2y ago

I mean is this a common issue with https and no content on the same machine? Or is it a possible configuration issue that action can be taken to resolve it but not evading it?

Up•2y ago

no. the https issue is that you're using an SSL cert and the machine doesn't trust it. either switch to serving http for localhost, or make the browser trust the cert you're using

KKSK＠🌸🎵🌸🎵🌸•2y ago

So if you look at my case 1 and 2 is kind of different case one does not even have an option to trust but case 2 does

Up•2y ago

case 1 likely has this proceed button, too, if you expand the details. chrome likes to hide that option because well, it is a security risk.

KKSK＠🌸🎵🌸🎵🌸•2y ago

no case 2 has it but it is hided also so I am aware of the option to show it

Up•2y ago

are you sending HSTS headers or anything?

KKSK＠🌸🎵🌸🎵🌸•2y ago

I believe not

Up•2y ago

(it should tell you about that in the details screen where the proceed button would normally be)

KKSK＠🌸🎵🌸🎵🌸•2y ago

let me provide a screenshot instead

KKSK＠🌸🎵🌸🎵🌸•2y ago

This is the error of case 1

KKSK＠🌸🎵🌸🎵🌸•2y ago

KKSK＠🌸🎵🌸🎵🌸•2y ago

this is what I mean by case 2

Up•2y ago

$ curl --http2 --head https://ichigo.icu/verify/12345/Nih3J9WShu83Hgb76Hj
curl: (56) Failure when receiving data from the peer

$ curl --http2 --head http://ichigo.icu/verify/12345/Nih3J9WShu83Hgb76Hj
curl: (52) Empty reply from server

$ curl --http2 --head https://ichigo.icu/verify/12345/Nih3J9WShu83Hgb76Hj
curl: (56) Failure when receiving data from the peer

$ curl --http2 --head http://ichigo.icu/verify/12345/Nih3J9WShu83Hgb76Hj
curl: (52) Empty reply from server

looks like you're running on http, not https

KKSK＠🌸🎵🌸🎵🌸•2y ago

The reason of you getting this is because there is bodymiddleware That filters ip Oh wait But your http work But it work on my machine

Up•2y ago

other than that, press F12, see if the dev console spits out any useful info

KKSK＠🌸🎵🌸🎵🌸•2y ago

so on my machine this is powershell

Up•2y ago

add --head --http2

KKSK＠🌸🎵🌸🎵🌸•2y ago

KKSK＠🌸🎵🌸🎵🌸•2y ago

no problem

Up•2y ago

so.. working as intended

KKSK＠🌸🎵🌸🎵🌸•2y ago

but this is case 4 where I accessed it through internet

KKSK＠🌸🎵🌸🎵🌸•2y ago

KKSK＠🌸🎵🌸🎵🌸•2y ago

case 1 still has issue

Up•2y ago

soo.. you're saying there's middleware blocking requests? are you 100% certain it is not blocking you here?

KKSK＠🌸🎵🌸🎵🌸•2y ago

yeah

KKSK＠🌸🎵🌸🎵🌸•2y ago

KKSK＠🌸🎵🌸🎵🌸•2y ago

so the top is from host machine case 1 the bottom is through internet case 4 the reason I am 100% is not blocking is case 3 where content is loaded

Up•2y ago

that is a different status code than 204 tho..

KKSK＠🌸🎵🌸🎵🌸•2y ago

KKSK＠🌸🎵🌸🎵🌸•2y ago

the top first command with verify is case 1 the top second command with battlecfg is case 3 the bottom with verify is case 4

Up•2y ago

https://stackoverflow.com/questions/58215104/whats-the-neterr-http2-protocol-error-about suggests it may be your web server dropping the connection preemptively under certain circumstances still.. do me that favor and just switch to not using GET for mutating data. that will possibly fix this issue, and if not, will at least prevent you some future headaches

KKSK＠🌸🎵🌸🎵🌸•2y ago

Yeah both work of using localhost with nocontent or not using it at all I was also suggested to have a frontend to handle https I was just curious is this by design that you cannot access no content httpget api with https and domain name from host machine

KKSK＠🌸🎵🌸🎵🌸•2y ago

because http does work on host machine with no content

KKSK＠🌸🎵🌸🎵🌸•2y ago

Gaming

Programming

HTTPS Local Network No Content Case