C#•3y ago

App.Config vs Resources.resx [Answered]

What's the main difference between them also why App.Config considered more secure approach ? 2nd question: Can i store type values with App.Config like ConsoleColor.Red ?

8 Replies

ServatorOP•3y ago

bump

Mayor McCheese•3y ago

app.config would store settings about your application from an execution standpoint, it's not particularly secure, especially for a client app. You have prebuilt structures for things like connection strings A resource file is typically used to store information about your application from a usage perspective, label fields, etc. There is a whole system for resource files in different languages for instance.

ServatorOP•3y ago

Also there is AppSettings I am really confused about those What would you prefer ?

Mayor McCheese•3y ago

AppSettings.json? App.Config is pretty rigid and in code has a lot of static helper classes, I don't personally like it, people tend to use ConfigurationManager class like it's going out of style and I think it promotes bad coding practices.

ServatorOP•3y ago

There is type safety issue too

Mayor McCheese•3y ago

for example:

class Something
{
  string GetData()
  {
    var value = ConfigurationManager.AppSettings["SomeKey"];
    return value;
  }
}

class Something
{
  string GetData()
  {
    var value = ConfigurationManager.AppSettings["SomeKey"];
    return value;
  }
}

I have no way to track usage of "SomeKey", other than searching code. I always advise not to use something like ConfigurationManager directly, but to build facades over it with AppSettings.json this is much easier to do.

ServatorOP•3y ago

ok thanks

Accord•3y ago

✅ This post has been marked as answered!

Gaming

Programming

App.Config vs Resources.resx [Answered]